no

The Secretary of State Says He Doesn’t Have to Look

0 Comments

On November 19, Secretary of State Cisco Aguilar asked a federal judge to throw out Barnhill v. Aguilar. It’s the move I expected. He didn’t answer my complaint, and he didn’t say my numbers are wrong. He argued that even if every fact I alleged is true, federal law doesn’t require his office to do anything about it.

That’s the whole dispute in one sentence: 9,607 people in Clark County hold two or more active voter registrations at different addresses, and the state’s chief election officer is telling a federal court he doesn’t have to look.

He says he doesn't have to look. Barnhill v. Aguilar: 9,607 Clark County voters with duplicate active registrations. Motion to dismiss filed Nov 19, 2026. An audit, not an accusation. Brad Lee Barnhill, electbarnhill.net.

What a motion to dismiss is

A motion to dismiss doesn’t argue the facts. At this stage, the court treats the facts in my complaint as true. The only question is whether, accepting those facts, the law gives me a claim. If the judge sides with the Secretary, the case ends and nobody ever checks those records. If she doesn’t, the case moves forward.

What the Secretary is arguing

The motion, filed by the Attorney General’s office, makes three points:

  • No duty to look. Federal law requires a “general program” that makes a “reasonable effort” to keep the rolls current. In his reading, nothing in it requires him to act when “a private citizen submits a spreadsheet or data analysis.”
  • Not enough about the program. He says my complaint describes records, not the state’s list-maintenance program, and that the law requires “a reasonable effort, not a perfect effort.”
  • No ineligible voter named. He argues I haven’t proven any particular registration is invalid, and suggests the duplicates may have innocent explanations like record updates or processing issues.

He also points me, again, to Nevada’s voter-challenge process, which requires a challenge based on personal knowledge, filed with the county clerk.

Think about what that means

Nobody personally knows 9,607 voters. If personal knowledge is the price of admission, no citizen can ever ask the state to check its own records, no matter what those records show.

The data I analyzed isn’t mine. It’s the Secretary’s, downloaded from his own website. Nevada now adds voters automatically, and last month a registration form came to my house for someone who has never lived here. I’m not asking him to trust me. I’m asking him to check his own work.

My own words, filed as an exhibit

From day one, I’ve said I’m not alleging fraud. My complaint to his office in May said so in a sworn affidavit. The motion quotes that line back as a reason to dismiss my case.

I’d write it again. Asking the state to check its records isn’t accusing anyone of anything. That’s what an audit is. Results, Not Noise.

What the motion doesn’t say

It doesn’t say my analysis is wrong. It doesn’t say anyone in his office checked the records I sent in May.

This is the Secretary’s second try at keeping my case from moving. In September he asked the court to put it on hold indefinitely. In October the judge said no and gave him until November 19 to respond to my complaint. He used that time to argue he doesn’t have to look.

What happens next

My response is due December 3. I’m writing it now, and I’m not going to preview it here. Now that I file electronically, it will be on the docket the day I file, and I’ll publish it here the same day, like every filing in this case. After that, the Secretary may file a reply, and Judge Dorsey will decide.

Read the Secretary’s motion (ECF No. 20) yourself. I publish every filing, win or lose.

Barnhill v. Aguilar — Case Timeline

May 20, 2026 Barnhill submitted a sworn complaint concerning alleged duplicate voter-registration records to the Nevada Secretary of State’s Elections Division and Clark County officials. See Who Will Protect Your Vote?

June 3–4, 2026 Formal notice was sent under the National Voter Registration Act. The Secretary of State’s office closed its file on June 4 without, according to the complaint, disputing the underlying data analysis.

September 4, 2026 Barnhill filed Barnhill v. Aguilar, Case No. 2:26-cv-02818-JAD-MDC, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada.

September 8, 2026 Secretary of State Francisco V. Aguilar and the Nevada Attorney General’s office were formally served with the lawsuit.

September 16, 2026 Barnhill filed an ex parte motion asking the Court to authorize him to register as a CM/ECF filing user and receive electronic service in this action under LR IC 2-1(b), since the standard registration process assumes an attorney applicant. See A Small Procedural Fight, With a Bigger Point Behind It.

September 28, 2026 Secretary of State Aguilar moved the Court to stay Barnhill’s case indefinitely until a separate lawsuit brought by the Republican National Committee is resolved. Barnhill opposed the stay and asked the Court to consolidate or coordinate the two cases instead. See While the Secretary of State Asks for More Time, I’m Asking the Court to Move Faster.

September 28, 2026 Barnhill’s Certificate of Interested Parties, dated September 28, certified that the only parties to the case are Barnhill, a Nevada voter, and the Secretary of State, with no corporate backers, affiliates, or insurer. See The Court Asked Who Has a Stake in My Lawsuit. The Honest Answer Is You.

October 1, 2026 Barnhill’s Opposition to the motions to stay and extend time (ECF No. 9), Motion to Consolidate (ECF No. 10), and Notice of Related Cases (ECF No. 11) were filed by mail. They were not entered on the docket until October 5. The Court has not yet ruled on the September 16 e-filing motion. See Equal Access to the Courthouse Shouldn’t Depend on Having a Lawyer.

October 6, 2026 Barnhill mailed a Notice of Lodging Proposed Order and Request for Ruling on the September 16 e-filing motion, with a proposed order attached. See I’ve Asked the Court to Rule on My E-Filing Request.

October 16, 2026 The Court denied the October 6 request for ruling as moot and set October 23 as the deadline for responses to Barnhill’s e-filing motion (ECF No. 14).

October 23, 2026 The response deadline on Barnhill’s e-filing motion passed with no opposition from the Secretary of State.

October 27, 2026 Two notices Barnhill mailed on October 19 were docketed (ECF Nos. 15 and 16). One notified the Court that the Secretary had not opposed the motion to consolidate, withdrew the consolidation request, and asked only for coordination of pretrial proceedings. See the notice.

October 29, 2026 Judge Jennifer A. Dorsey denied the Secretary’s motion to stay, denied the motion to consolidate, and gave the Secretary until November 19 to answer the complaint (ECF No. 17). See The Secretary of State Asked the Court to Park My Case. The Judge Said No.

October 29, 2026 Magistrate Judge Maximiliano D. Couvillier III granted Barnhill’s unopposed motion to register as a CM/ECF filer and receive electronic service (ECF No. 18). The order arrived by mail on November 4. See It Took 43 Days to Get Permission to File Like a Lawyer. The Order Came by Mail.

November 5, 2026 Barnhill filed his first document through CM/ECF, a Certificate of Compliance with the e-filing order (ECF No. 19), attaching his PACER e-filing status for the District of Nevada showing “Active.” It reached the docket the same day. See The Order Came by Mail. My Next Filing Didn’t.

November 19, 2026 Instead of answering the complaint, the Secretary of State moved to dismiss it (ECF No. 20), with an appendix of exhibits that includes Barnhill’s May 20 complaint to the Elections Division and the Secretary’s June 4 closure letter (ECF No. 21). Barnhill’s response is due December 3. See The Secretary of State Says He Doesn’t Have to Look.

Latest update: The Secretary of State Says He Doesn’t Have to Look


The election is over. This case isn’t.

Get to know me · Join the campaign · Donate

Categories: